Shelter Island, NY schools
1 public schools, ranked by 2024–25 statewide rank (click a column to sort) · typical home value $1.77M*
| 85th / 169 | Shelter Island School | Other | White 64% | 55% | 55% | 193 | 35% |
*Median of zip-level typical home values (ZHVI). Data Provided by Zillow Group.